Mike Howell
Technical Support Specialist
Stator core testing is a critical but sometimes overlooked step in the repair and rewinding of electric motors. In this paper, Mike Howell explains why service centers should evaluate the condition of a stator core before rewinding and verify that the rewinding process itself has not damaged the core.
The primary objectives of stator core testing are to determine whether the existing stator core is suitable for continued service and to ensure that procedures such as burnout and winding removal have not degraded core performance. These goals align with EASA's commitment to maintaining or improving the energy efficiency of repaired rotating electrical machines. Since core losses typically account for 15% to 25% of the total losses in a squirrel-cage induction motor, excessive core loss can significantly reduce motor efficiency, especially in machines operating below rated load. Direct measurement of core loss is often impractical in repair facilities, particularly when motors arrive in a failed or inoperable condition, making alternative testing methods necessary.
The paper focuses on the conventional loop test, also known as a ring test or core flux test, which has long been used to assess stator core condition. Rather than directly measuring operating efficiency, the loop test provides a practical indication of the health of the stator laminations by magnetizing the core and observing power consumption, temperature rise, and localized heating. Howell traces the origins of the method to work published by H. R. Tomlinson in 1952 and explains how the test simulates the magnetic conditions found in normal machine operation. EASA recommends conducting the test at approximately 1.3 Tesla (85,000 lines per square inch), a magnetic flux density that provides meaningful results while remaining below the saturation point of most electrical steels. This standardization allows repair facilities to compare before-and-after results and evaluate changes caused by the repair process.
A significant portion of the paper addresses the practical challenges encountered in service centers, particularly when testing smaller stators. Small motors may require impractically high coil turn counts when conventional test voltages are used. To overcome this issue, Howell presents the use of low-voltage variable autotransformers and innovative quick-connect multi-turn test coils that reduce setup time and make testing economically feasible. He discusses key design considerations such as conductor size, resistance, connector quality, and current-carrying capability, demonstrating how poorly designed test coils can significantly distort results by introducing excessive cable losses. The paper also reviews instrumentation requirements, emphasizing the importance of accurate measurements of voltage, current, power, power factor, and temperature. Affordable handheld power meters and thermal imaging devices are highlighted as practica tools that allow service centers to obtain reliable data and easily identify hot spots.
Howell further explores how test results should be interpreted. Three primary assessment criteria are identified: minimal temperature rise, uniform heating without hot spots, and acceptable core loss. A localized hot spot exceeding approximately 10°C to 15°C above the average core temperature may indicate damaged laminations requiring repair. The discussion then examines one of the most debated aspects of stator core testing: calculating watts per pound. The author explains how different approaches to accounting for cable losses and whether to include stator teeth in the core weight calculation can significantly affect the final result. While EASA's procedure uses only the back iron weight and includes cable loss in the measured value, Howell emphasizes that technicians should understand the implications of each method and apply testing procedures consistently. The paper concludes by reinforcing that meaningful comparisons can only be made when pre- and post-rewind tests are performed under identical conditions, ensuring confidence that the stator core remains suitable for continued service and that motor efficiency has not been compromised by the repair process.
Top Takeaways
- Test before and after rewinding. Baseline and post-repair testing provide the only reliable way to determine whether the rewind process has affected core condition or efficiency.
- Stator core condition directly impacts motor efficiency. Because core losses can represent 15% to 25% of total motor losses, damaged laminations can significantly increase operating costs and reduce performance.
- The loop test remains the industry-standard practical assessment method. When performed correctly, it provides valuable information about insulation damage, lamination defects, and overall core integrity.
- Consistency is more important than absolute numbers. Test results are most meaningful when procedures, equipment, flux density, and calculation methods remain the same from one test to the next.
- Watch for hot spots. Localized temperature rises of approximately 10°C to 15°C above the surrounding core temperature may indicate damaged laminations that require corrective action.
- Testing small motors is practical with the right equipment. Low-voltage power sources and appropriately designed multi-turn test coils can make core testing economical even for smaller machines.
- Test equipment design matters. Improperly sized conductors, poor connections, and unaccounted cable losses can distort results and lead to inaccurate conclusions about core condition.
- Understand how core loss calculations are derived. Differences in weighing methods and treatment of cable losses can affect watts-per-pound values, making it important to understand the methodology behind the numbers.
- Thermal imaging can enhance diagnostics. Infrared inspection tools make it easier to identify localized heating and document core condition during testing.
- The goal is confidence before investing in a rewind. Knowing the condition of the stator core before repair helps ensure the motor can be restored to reliable, energy-efficient operation.
Related Reference and Training Materials
Print